Open vs closed headphones: How To Select The Best One

Eric Chan

When listening to your favorite audiobook or music playlist, it is more fun to use headphones. The sound quality is higher, and you can almost feel the music in your soul. Open-back headphones are ideal for home listening because they function better in quiet environments. On the other hand, closed-back headphones are amazing when you need to concentrate on activities such as working out, studying, going for walks and running. In the next section, we shall discuss open Vs closed headphones.

What Are Open Vs Closed-Back Headphones?

You wouldn't notice how many people use open-back headphones until you actually understood the differences between open-back and closed-back headphones. You are probably using open head headphones and didn't even realize it. The easiest distinction between open-back and closed-back headphones is that open-back headphones have multiple perforations in them and allow you to hear background noise. In addition, open-back headphones allow for sound leakage.

Suppose you are a person who enjoys listening to music for long periods of time while multitasking. Then, closed-back headphones are for you. This is because closed-back headphones block outside noise in a noisy environment. This means that they are perfect for closing off external ambient noise. In addition, the ear cups in close headphones are larger and hence allow for higher sound isolation. As a result, closed headphones offer a better experience in your day-to-day life, especially if you are in a noisy environment such as using public transport.

Generally speaking, open Vs closed headphones might have a bunch of differences, but they both have amazing listening experience in different ideal situations. They are the best headphones. Something to consider is that even though closed-back headphones have larger ear cups that block out noise isolation, they cause ear fatigue over a period of time. They are also completely sealed from the back. Headphones have a variety of uses, such as listening to music, listening to audiobooks, podcasts and recorded audio.

Differences Between Open Vs Closed-Back Headphones.

1) Structure

Open-back headphones have multiple perforations in their structure that allows sound leakage out of the ear cups. This feature can be both an advantage and disadvantage depending on how you look at it. They are perfect for a quiet environment such as the park because they have a more open natural sound. You are also able to listen to external sounds without a problem. Open headphones don't close off the outside world, ideal for everyday listening.

In comparison, closed-back headphones have large ear cups and an outside shell that cover your ears fully and enhance sound isolation. In addition, they have a passive noise cancellation feature great for blocking out noise. Closed headphones tend to have a high bass response and, because of this, are ideal for critical listening. They, however, do not have a natural sound and have the effect of closing off outside sounds so that you get to listen to higher-quality music.

2) Noise cancellation

Open-back headphones are known for their lack of noise cancellation feature. This can be particularly disheartening when you're in public places and would like to listen to music comfortably. This results in frustrations and impatience. Nowadays, we like to listen to music when doing mundane activities. This seems a little complicated without the noise cancellation feature. In order to counter this disadvantage, increasing your volume should do the trick, but this could be imperative to your hearing.

On the other hand, closed-back headphones are great at noise isolation which is ideal for public scenarios and shutting out the outside world. Audiophiles explain the feeling of using closed-back headphones as being an immersive experience. Audio professionals also love these headphones because they allow them to listen to technical aspects of music. In addition, DJs, audio engineers and studio producers prefer to use closed headphones.

3) Recording

Closed-back headphones are primarily made for studio recording. Because of their ability to maximize sound and rarely leak sound, they are used to track musical instruments and result in a clear sound without any distortion. However, closed-back headphones produce low frequencies and, therefore, a high bass response that doesn't depict the actual sound of certain instruments, which some people may see as a problem while others see this as an added advantage.

Open-back headphones are not particularly made for recording because of their inability to block outside noise as well as allow for high sound escapes. However, open-back headphones have the advantage of producing an open and innate sound. Some could say that this feature is pertinent to hearing different instruments in a particular playlist. Nevertheless, most audio professionals agree that open-back headphones aren't ideal for studio recording.

4) Heavy bass

Closed-back headphones are known for their low frequency, which results in the heavy bass of the headphones in general. Therefore, they do not necessarily depict the actual sound levels of other musical instruments because of the heavy bass. This, however, is an advantage for other scenarios, such as in the club, where heavy bass guarantees a better immersive experience for both the DJs and their listeners. One thing to consider is that larger headphone drivers, otherwise known as transducers, produce a much heavier bass.

Open headphones have a lesser impact when it comes to heavy bass because they have too much sound leakage, less air pressure, and audio spill . To counter this disadvantage, they produce a much clearer sound and do not dull the senses, much like mind hearing. This produces a more natural sound. You can still listen to music or audiobook while being aware of your surroundings. Thus open-back headphones are much suited for mixing, especially when done in an acoustic room. They, however, cannot contain sound or keep it out.

5) Audio spill

Open-back vs closed headphones have the disability of sound leakage. This also affects semi-open-back headphones. However, the listening experience of this is that you can simultaneously listen to other external sounds such as nature, cars and other people. The perforations in the ear cups allow air and sound to pass through, whereby they cannot suppress sound, unlike closed headphones. This has the unwanted effect of people being able to hear your personal music playlist.

Closed-back headphones, in comparison, are the best headphones to use in order to avoid the problem of an audio spill. They are sealed and do not have perforations which makes for an overall good sound clarity. In addition, a closed-back headphone is made in such a way that they reduce noise reduction by 10 decibels just by wearing them. After turning on the headphones, the noise is pretty much non-existent, and the only sound you can here is your music playing.

Factors To Consider Before Buying open or closed Headphones.

a) Personal preference

From the moment you discovered the difference between an open headphone and a closed-back headphone, you must have had an automatic personal preference. You naturally leaned towards one more than the other. If you liked the open-back headphones more, their drawbacks didn't bother you much and vice versa with the closed-back headphones. This personal preference is one of the factors that will help you decide which headphones to buy.

The physical difference in headphone design between the open back and closed-back headphones is that the open-closed headphones have multiple perforations in them, and they are flatter in size. On the other hand, the closed-back headphones are much chunkier and have larger cups that cover the ears fully. The headphone style will also differ from different brands.

b) Cost

Closed-back headphones have many advantages to them, but the most important one would be price. One pair of closed headphones cost from 5USD to hundreds of dollars. They are handy in an array of sizes, shapes, and many colors. There are a variety of different headphone types, and it is up to you to choose your preferred option.

Open-back vs closed headphones are used for specific uses, but one easy use is casual listening. These gorgeous pieces of technology go for a whopping $75. They are expensive headphones because they offer a much natural and even sound. Open-back headphones come in a variety of colors and styles. At certain seasons, however, different brands offer exclusive deals on both open and semi-open headphones. As mentioned earlier, these headphones lack better isolation as sound and air pass freely.

c) Durability

Closed-back headphones are very durable because they are sealed completely and do not allow moisture to build up in them. This makes them last longer. They also have up to 2 years warranty. In the rare case that they malfunction by either completely not working or working in one earpiece, you should produce a copy of your warranty and get your headphones replaced. Having known this, investing in a good pair should serve you for a long time.

Open-back headphones may be natural sounding, but alas, they are not very durable. This is due to the fact that they are prone to water damage because of the many depressions that they possess. There could be moisture buildup in them over a short period of time, and this could ultimately be detrimental to these headphones. The open-back headphone is a great choice if you are into listening to your audio in a quiet environment. Thus tend to need replacements every couple of months.

d) Sound

One factor we can all agree upon is that headphones have one ultimate function; sound. Depending on what type of music you like listening to, open Vs closed-back headphones is a choice you have to make. If you prefer classical music, open-back headphones are well suited for you. They produce a much lighter sound. Despite their drawback of sound leaking, which would mean that people would probably be able to hear what you are listening to, these headphones would much rather be used at home.

However, if you fancy heavy music with low frequencies, then closed-back headphones are definitely for you. They are efficient even at lower volume. Their large ear cups completely seal outside sound, thus only letting in the music that you are listening to. Some would say that closed-back headphones are perfect audiophile headphones specifically designed for audiophile listening. They are a great pair of headphones for commuting and focusing on important activities.

e) Comfortability

We need to understand the closed-back design in order to choose whether these headphones are for us. Its prominent ear cups are hard to miss because they cover your ears almost completely. A closed-back design has the effect of having good stereo imaging, which creates a sense of depth and width of sound. It is a given that these headphones are perfect for sound isolation, but they are not suitable for long periods of time due to ear fatigue.

Open-back headphones take the cake on this factor without a doubt. You might simply refuse to purchase closed-back headphones because they do not offer much comfiness, disregarding all its advantages. Open headphones manage to counter the problem of comfiness by having many grills in their housing which allows for airflow and sound waves to move freely. The stereo field in these headphones processes incoming digital audio for the best listening experience.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

(i) Do people hear what I'm listening to with my open-back headphones?

Yes, others around you can hear what you are listening to. This is due to the multiple perforations that are on the surface of the headphones, which allow air to pass freely.

(ii) Are open-back headphones better than closed-back headphones?

They both have their advantages and cons but depending on what and where you would these headphones is a factor to consider. For example, if you mostly commute and use public transport as well as being in a professional setting, closed-back headphones are suited for you. However, if you like to be aware of your surrounding while listening to music, open-back headphone is the right choice for you.

(iii) What distinction is there between open back Vs closed headphones?

Open-back headphones are flatter and have many perforations in them, which has the result of giving a clear sound, while closed-back headphones have ear cups and an outer shell of plastic that cover the ears entirely and are completely sealed.

The Bottom Line

Before considering what headphones to buy, it is important to understand the pros and cons of the open Vs closed-back headphones debate. Depending on your activities or what you do on a daily basis will determine what headphones work best for you. For example, if you work in a music studio, open-back headphones are best suited for you. Similarly, if you work in a professional setting and use headphones, closed-back headphones better serve you.

Leave a Comment